Wisest of the crowds

The National Association of Realtors reported that their “Pending Home Sales Index” for July fell to its lowest level since the post Sept. 11, 2001 period as a result of tightening credit for Jumbo mortgage loans (loans over $417,000).

So what is this index? Directly from the NAR release:

“The Pending Home Sales Index is based on a large national sample, typically representing about 20 percent of transactions for existing-home sales. In developing the model for the index, it was demonstrated that the level of monthly sales-contract activity from 2001 through 2004 parallels the level of closed existing-home sales in the following two months. “

It seems that Three Stooges of the mortgage ecosystem, lenders (Curly), Wall Street mortgage underwriters (Moe), and mortgage buyers (Larry) all woke up after a night of drinking and decided never again (well, at least for a few weeks!) ! These Jumbo loans are NOT purchased by the quasi-government agencies Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac whose job it is to purchase loans from lenders so that lenders have the funds to make more loans - a mechanism to facilitate home ownership for average and lower income home buyers. Jumbo loans do not qualify so they must be either held by lenders or sold to investors via wall street. Since Fannie and Freddie have continued to support loans at the low-end while the high-end has lost free market support, Jumbo’s have shut down for the minority and have gotten MUCH more expensive for the majority. Not surprisingly, the Western part of the US, which has the highest home prices and presumably the most Jumbo loans, got hit hardest being down a whopping 20.8% to 82.3 versus 89.9 nationally.

Will this last? No way. This is a temporary disruption as people reorient their perspective to risk. Will the cost of jumbo’s (as a spread to treasury securities) increase? You can bet on it!

Yesterday, Russel Shaw at Bloodhound Blog posted a note he received from a young person sniffing the real estate industry. Entitled “I’ll bring you a big basket of cash if you’ll let me sell your house for free” Shaw responds to the young persons overt question whether the industry is crowded and the covert question as to whether pricing can be used as a competitive weapon. Shaw tells the young person not to use pricing to differentiate (and yes there are too many agents). This got me thinking. If EVERY industry has price discrimination, why doesn’t housing? (yes there are firms like Redfin and FSBO’s but traction is light) This is not whether orange people get better prices than purple people. Not that kind of discrimination. This is you using e-trade for stock execution rather than Morgan Stanley. Does variation in transaction costs make sense for housing?

I am not an economist but here goes.

The graph above is what Shaw is saying. There is one price for transactions (or something like that) and that you should stick to it. An economist would say that given the demand at that price, sales will be S1. Lets see if we add new prices…..

So by adding new prices, we tap into a larger amount of the total demand. From an industry perspective, price discrimination (price variation) yields HIGER total number of transactions. This is why airlines use it. This is why software companies use it. This is why EVERYONE uses it. Ever clipped a coupon? Ever cashed in on frequent flier miles? This is price discrimination at work.

So the one thing to consider that might debunk this basic economic notion is whether the demand curve (in blue) is in fact oddly shaped. Lets take a look….

So if demand is the same regardless of price then Mr. Shaw is correct. In fact, if demand in the real estate industry is oblivious to transaction costs than Mr. Shaw and all the other realtors are bloody idiots for not raising prices. So I guess the question is this: is demand for housing sensitive to transaction costs or not? If it is, like most things, then everyone stands to be better off by offering differing levels of pricing (and service). If demand for housing is not sensitive to transaction costs…then put your orders in for those new german cars because margins are about to get much better.

Giddy up little doggy!